Skip to main content

Why We Fight

On Sunday night, I watched the film Why We Fight with my wife and some friends over at the Dawg Haus. It had been a film that I'd wanted to see ever since it was released a couple years ago, but I finally got around to watching it.

I am glad that I did.

Not that the content surprised me to a great extent, but more that it caused me to think more deeply about the ugliness of war and the "military-industrial complex" (coined by Eisenhower) that pervades the American landscape. Over the years, I have fluctuated greatly in my views on the topic of war: pre-emptive strikes, nuclear war, torture, just wars, policing and protecting the world, advancing "democracy", fighting for oil, et al. Largely, this stuff makes me sad and disturbed.

This film is not a documentary, per se; however, I am not sure that I've ever witnessed a true "documentary." Why We Fight is trying to make a point. There are interviews with prominent figures from pro and anti-war camps. It is certainly a more balanced than a film such as Sicko (although, I really liked that one). This film reveals the ease with which we can turn to war, when we have interests in those nations which will better our own economy. When we have thousands of American jobs and corporate cash flows that depend on our production of weapons (read: murders), won't we find it a bit more easy to go to war? My friend, Stacey, brought up a necessary point: don't be too quick to judge the leadership of our country, it is much easier to judge from the outside. That said, we need to keep our elected leaders accountable to standards of integrity when and where we can.

I think that every American should watch this film. You can view it for free here: http://quicksilverscreen.com/watch?video=30172

As one who is trying to follow the way of Jesus, I find it difficult to support war to the extent that many Americans have (That support and patriotism has certainly wained over the past generation. Though, thank God that we stood up against Nazism, for example). Is there evil in the world? Yes. Are there unjust and evil dictators who cause genocide? Yes. Are there WMDs? Yes (just not in Iraq, or at least before we arrived). Is Wahhabism (extremist, fundamental Islam) a real threat to peace and civility? Yes. Are there nations and rebel groups who refuse to dialogue in a diplomatic manner? Yes. Are there nations and leaders who would do the unthinkable to maintain their access to oil and thus a prosperous economy? Yes. Are there political leaders who steal money and subsequently food, medicine, shelter and clean water from their people? Yes.

I do not want to be naive or turn a blind eye to this injustice. I do not want to just pretend that we can ignore bombings and mass murder. There is certainly a time for peace and unfortunately a time for war. We live in a broken world, but it is a world where we as Christians must take a stand along with Christ. Christ stood against self-protection. He said to give rather than take. He said to love our enemies and to pray for those who persecute us. This is not to say that Jesus was a softy. He did not hesitate to rebuke his contemporaries who were leading people astray (it would be better for those leaders to have a millstone tied around their necks). Our allegiances are to God's kingdom, not to the American empire. America is not a theocracy, although many conservatives in American may wish it were. We live in a democratic state with leaders and decision makers who are not Christ-followers, but we are called to pray for and respect them. Somehow, we are to figure out how to respect Caesar and give him his money that he needs to run a government, but when that government takes money from the hungry, poor and uneducated and uses it to build up a weapons cache large enough to destroy 10 planet Earths? Come on.

May God have mercy on us and may we be immersed in his love, justice and peace.

Comments

Ben said…
I agree - I have a really hard time supporting war seeing how easily it can be mis-managed and mis-led. Even beyond that - How heavy a burden it is to justify the amount of pain and death that comes from war on both sides (and not just soldiers). What happened to giving a man your shirt as well when he asks for your coat?

Defense is one thing, but I can't trust pre-emption or retaliation when we have so much to gain by fighting.

Do you think we would still be at war if we were paying for it?
Jonathan said…
By "if we were paying for it" do you mean if everyone had to mail in personal checks or if it was on our soil? I am not sure I am following you on that last question...

Popular posts from this blog

What were my memorable books of 2016?

I don't read nearly as much these days. Or maybe not as much as I'd prefer in some idealistic (unreal) world where I get to spend a few hours a day soaking up good literature.

Mostly, I'm reading Goodnight, Gorilla, There's a Rumble in the Jungle or Fancy Nancy. (Let's be honest. I actually like children's literature.) And at bedtime, Anna has fallen in love with (routine?) my narration of homegrown stories. (In case you're wondering, I'm a terrible storyteller. I wish I were that dad whose stories inspire her to one day look back and marvel at the whimsical, imaginative stories I cooked up at bedtime, but alas, probably not. I'm learning slowly, though, at least about what kind of story she will likely enjoy.)

But in the margins of here and there, I have found time for a sampling of books in 2016. Here are some memorable ones:

More of Less, Joshua Becker

A helpful guide on minimizing excess (possessions) so you can focus on what's most important…

Today's Awakening - With malice toward none, with charity for all

“With malice toward none, with charity for all, with firmness in the right as God gives us to see the right, let us strive on to finish the work we are in, to bind up the nation's wounds, to care for him who shall have borne the battle and for his widow and his orphan, to do all which may achieve and cherish a just and lasting peace among ourselves and with all nations.” President Lincoln’s Second Inaugural Address “How are you doing today?” she asked with a smile. “Not great,” I replied in haste, opting for honesty over pleasantry. “I’m sad and angry,” I told the woman on my way to work.
Like many of you, I awoke today in disbelief. How could *this* man be our President elect? How could our country – the great US of A, land of liberty and justice for all - knowingly choose a man who unashamedly propagates racism, xenophobia, sexism, isolationism, greed, fear and disregard for the stewardship of this planet? What will we say to our children? I grieve with my friends and neighbors …

Another RSVP this Christmas season? Advent beckons

It's the most wonderful time of the year. For me, at least, it typically is.

I truly enjoy this Christmas season full of festive cheer: hanging lights on the fir tree, unpacking the ornaments and memories from a dusty Christmas bin, chestnuts roasting on an open fire, making snow angels, sipping egg nog, watching Home Alone, wrapping gifts. Christmas!

As I grow older, though, my eyes are obtaining new lenses to see the gorge that often lies between Christmas and Advent.

Though the wider culture doesn't use the term "Christmas" any more, in view of the diverse beliefs represented in Western culture, Christmas still stands a monolithic tree whose branches reach wide in the culture. We've built an entire consumer mindset as well as a strong dose of nostalgia from this festive season of giving, having transgressed a two-thousand millennia wide boundary water from the banks of Bethlehem's stable. For many, Christmas - or "the holidays" - is a wonderfull…